Indeed, a KILLER film---in more ways than one.
This is a movie that fits generally into the “Todd Solandz lite” category I identified with “Pumpkin” and Miguel Arteta’s movies, especially his recent “The Good Girl.” Compare “About Schmidt” with those two and you see how sour its worldview is. The latter is relatively filled to the brim with horribly detailed observations of Middle American stupidity and bad taste. Inhabitants of the Napa Valley, beware! Solandz lite is a style that gets extremely varied readings from different audiences. I saw an early matinee of “About Schmidt” in Berkeley with an older crowd dying to laugh--and they squeezed out only three good guffaws through the course of the whole thing. I conclude that if you’re near Warren Schmidt’s age, this movie isn’t half as much fun as young people tend to think. It's a cautionary tale---but how credible is the witness? Alexander Payne is peering in at a stage of life he doesn’t know firsthand; he has also downgraded the social details of his story from the Louis Begley novel in the direction of farce and cruel satire.
I’m surprised more people don’t see how bitter and dismissive Payne’s view of Schmidt and everybody in (or just below) Schmidt’s world really is. This has a very different tone from “Election” and it’s a grim one---studiously eschewing, by the way, the laughs and audience nudges Nicolson was willing to put in. No wonder the director has moved away from Nebraska now. He’s burning his bridges in this one. True, Kathy Bates and crew are good for some smiles but Jack Nicolson is kept in tight rein.
But how successfully? Nicolson's very history is an ironic commentary on the role---he cannot escape that fact. Is his performance so wonderful? Only if you give extra points to an actor for taking a part unsuited to his flamboyant talents. A dubious piece of casting but an excellent career move for Payne. He has gained the limelight and nudged Solandz lite closer to mainstream attention than the “Pumpkin” and “Good Girl” crew could possibly have done.
“About Schmidt” is an arresting movie, but its mean spiritedness is even more saddening than the hopeless vacuity of its hero’s life. The movie means to be tragicomedy, but there can be little comedy where there is so much restraint, and no tragedy where there is so little sympathy. I would not recommend this movie to anyone looking for a good time.
Nonetheless, a must-see for film buffs.
_________________________
P.s. I learned about something new: the mullet. Dictionaries say it’s a fish but the Web is full of fan sites—or something—for the hairstyle. An example among many of Payne’s keen observation of social indicators.