THE NAZIS: A WARNING FROM HISTORY (2007-Lawrence Rees)
This excellent BBC TV production by Lawrence Rees gives you the complete rise and fall of the Nazi Party of Germany, in six parts.
I have to correct the date- this series was made in 1997, not 2007- I can't seem to edit the top line of the post...
I'll post about each part. It is history, and it is fascinating. And it is definitely a warning from history.
Some of the images and stories and testimonies here are horrific. This is about humans, and how they relate/react to their surroundings in times of crisis.
It contains some of the harshest and cruellest lessons history has to teach us. I'll do my best to review the series.
It is narrated by Samuel West and I recommend it to anybody.
To see how World War I shaped what was to become World War II is a steep learning curve, how the armistice on Nov. 11, 1918 angered every German and planted a seed for the future that would horrify the world.
After I've posted on the six parts I wouldn't mind people's thoughts. I'd like to hear everybody's opinion here, whomever is willing to discuss it.
part I: HELPED INTO POWER
Narrator Samuel West informs us that Nazism was borne out of the first World War.
To Germany's surprise, the war suddenly stopped on November 11, 1918.
Herbert Richter, a German WWI vet tells us: Of course we were angry. The front line troops didn't feel defeated. We wondered why the armistice occured so quickly. Why did we have to vacate our positions in such a hurry?
The German troops felt betrayed. They felt that the 2 million Germans who made the ultimate sacrifice were betrayed.
Betrayed by Marxists and Jews.
We're told that after the war the allies continued to blockade Germany. Certain conditions created a Revolution. In Munich, the capital of Bavaria, families were still suffering, and it shocked the troops. Millions of Germans were hungry. Thousands more were dying of tuberculosis and influenza. Politics were polarized. In the face of crisis, Conservatives and Socialists each became radicalized. In 1919 there was lots of turmoil, and in Munich a left-wing takeover took place. A Soviet-style government was created, and government troops were sent to quash the rebellion.
There was open fighting in the streets of Munich- firefights, and we see historic footage of it.
More than 500 were killed. A participant right-wing mercenary Fridolin von Spaun testifies: They got what they deserved. They wanted to plunge Germany into chaos.
Son of a Jewish Communist Leader Eugene Levine enlightens us: In Germany the impression gradually took hold that Bolshevism and Judaism are basically the same. I find it natural that a generally anti-Jewish attitude became widespread. The Jews were convenient scapegoats, totally to blame for the country's ills.
Captain Ernst Rohm and Corporal Adolph Hitler had the same deep hatred of Communists and Jews. They met when Hitler was 30, in 1919, and they both were part of the small German Workers party. Like thousands of ex-soldiers in Munich, Hitler was drifting, without a regular job.
Narrator Samuel West kindly tells us that Hitler found out he had a talent for channelling his anger at the way the war had ended into fiery powerful speeches. When he spoke, he was able to convince anyone within earshot that he was a man with a point.
The Versailles Peace Treaty was brutal- Germany had to pay reparations to the Victors of the war. In the 1920's, inflation in Germany spiralled out of control.
You'd pay billions in Reichsmarks for one sausage. Batshit nuts. People would bemoan that it couldn't go on anymore. We're told it was a real collapse of society. Then we're told of how the debate began for the need for a strong man.
That call for a strong man got louder and louder, simply because democracy achieved nothing.
The German Workers "National Socialist" party (NAZI, for short) stood up and said Versailles was a crime and the Jews were behind it.
Hitler would deliver these rousing, dynamic, uncompromising speeches and he started to attract prominent Bavarians to the Nazi party.
WWI flying ace Hermann Goering joined because it was Revolutionary to him, not ideological.
Heinrich Himmler wanted Germans to be Heroes, not cowards, so the Nazi party appealed to him.
Many more would join the Nazi ranks in the years to come.
We're told of the French troops, and how they would humiliate Germans when collecting reparations in the early 1920's. There was widespread hunger, squalor and poverty. "The French ruled with an Iron Hand" we're told by ex-Nazi party member Jutta Rutiger. "Perhaps they simply wanted to take revenge".
French troops violently occupied the Ruhr, and it was a crisis. Hitler and the Nazi party decided to ACT.
On November 8th, 1923 Hitler interrupted a right-wing political meeting and called for a National Revolution to start in Bavaria and overthrow the left-wing government in Berlin. The next day the Nazis marched through Munich to gain support. They were stopped by the police. Shots were fired, the marchers were routed, Hitler fled the scene and when the dust settled, 4 policemen and 16 Nazi party members were dead.
Hitler was tried, and he served one month in prison. In 1924, the Nazis seemed almost irrelevant. The German economy was turning around, shit was becoming increasingly bourgeoisie. Inflation was back to single digits. The Weimar government had solved the reparations problem we're told by borrowing cash from the USA, using it to pay back the Brits and the French.These good times were financed by short-term credit, and there were Germans against this "Weimar Decadence". The Wandervogel movement were anti-rich Germans who wanted an old-fashioned lifestyle.
We're told the Hitler Youth movement capitalized on this. Here were young people and their mentors shouting "GERMANY FIRST!"
Their slogan was "GERMANY AWAKE!"
In the 20's, the Nazi party was small, but radical. They promised that if elected, they would strip German Jews of their citizenship and would even expel them. They held an opinion of "WORLD JEWRY", which they believed wanted to gain power, to Rule the World. They believed in and openly preached about this "World Jewish Conspiracy". Along with their anti-Semitism they felt VIOLENCE was necessary. They had their own para-military wing, the Brown Shirts, whose job it was to intimidate others and to drum up support.
Towering over this small party was the personality of the man called "The Fuhrer", Adolph Hitler. The whole party was structured around his Leadership, and would continue even when Germany ruled much of Europe.
part II: CHAOS AND CONSENT
Our narrator Samuel West lays it on us that the Nazis were obsessed with images of "order".
Their mentality was that one person is a part of the National Community. But in Germany the Nazis only created the illusion of order.
In the beginning of 1933 there was a feeling in the air for a wonderful period, era- the True Movement- the German Heart was welling with National Pride.
Manfred von Schroder (Nazi German diplomat 1933-45): The concentration camps- so what? What, the Communists wouldn't have done the same thing? This is a revolution.
Concentration camps were hastily built for Communists and Socialists. They were all rounded up and put in camps. Not death camps- those weren't in the cards just yet, and most prisoners were out within one year. Herman Goering announced that "Scores were being settled".
This was an atmosphere of chaotic terror, we're told.
People were arrested left and right, being threatened with time in Dachau. Each street cleaner felt he was responsible for matters that he never understood!
One of the Jewish Communists who was imprisoned, Josef Felder, speaks: I was put in chains.And the guard brought a plate with white sausages and pretzels. He held them out to me. "This would make a nice last meal before your execution", he said. "But you're not even worth this, you Scoundrel". Then he brought me a rope, showing me the best way to hang myself. I told him I won't do it. I have a family.
Beatings and psychological torture were commonplace. There is lots of historic footage in this series- it is seriously chock full of vintage film of these desperate times. In 1933 the camps were an oppressive tool, but not yet for systematic murder. In fact, to many Germans these camps were an acceptable part of the Nazi Revolution.The Nazis had made the Jews scapegoats for World War I and boycotted them. They boycotted their shops, they held public burnings of Jewish books.
Ernst Rohm wanted his stormtroopers to integrate into the German Army, and the Army was horrified. German Army Officer Johann A.G. Kielmansegg tells us: The stormtroopers were almost hated by the soldiers. Because of their appearance, their behavior. It became incresingly clear to the Army that Rohm, the highest commander of the stormtroopers, was attempting somehow to take over the Armed Forces. He was trying to become Minister for the Armed Forces. He wanted to create his own army.
Rohm made an enemy out of Heinrich Himmler. Hitler had to curb the "zeal" of the stormtroopers' effects on the party. Himmler plotted Rohm's downfall. We're told he concocted a story that Rohm was plotting a coup. Hitler believed him. 1934- Rohm is arrested at home and taken to a prison. Two days later he was shot. The Army is glad that the stormtroopers' power is now moderated. To show their gratitude, they publicly pledge allegiance to the Fuhrer en masse, who, after Hindenburg's death wasn't just Chancellor, but Germany's Head of State.
A German soldier is asked how seriously he and his comrades took that Oath to Hitler:
A soldier takes it very serious. Oath is Oath. I can't break my Oath. I might commit suicide if I planned something else! This is very serious, the Oath, for a Soldier.
Next we learn of Hitler's daily routine, and he was a fairly lazy fuck, by my estimation.
He normally appeared just before lunch, read some newspapers, read press briefs, and then went in for lunch. At his mansion on top of the mountain it was even worse. He often wouldn't leave his room until after 2 PM, and then go for lunch. He spent most afternoons taking a walk, feeding deer. In the evening, straight after dinner, there were films.
We're told that in 12 short years Hitler created more confusion in government than has ever existed. He took the view that on certain files, most things would work themselves out. IF one did not interfere...
For all his laziness in his castles, when he was out in public, especially at the stadium in Nuremburg, he was Mr. Fiery Speech. He was a man of ACTION. Here's Hitler giving a speech, which we see him deliver with fire and brimstone:
We want to be one people. And you, my young people, are to become this people.
You cannot help but be joined with us. Today, the extended ranks of our movement are marching victoriously through Germany, and I know that you will join those ranks. And we know, before us lies Germany. Within us resides Germany. And behind us comes Germany.
We're told that he was meant to be seen as the all-knowing, all-powerful Leader.
The system he prevailed over represented order, but the reality was anything but.
Far from being a very structured order of Command, in fact it was very disorganized and chaotic.
There was no collective Head of State, and the Leader is doing nothing but DICTATING. It was remarkable.
He was surrounded by acolytes, people who went out of their way to find favor with the Fuhrer. They strove to be near him, accompanying him on trips that suited his fancy. Even though he was a lazy sod, Hitler DID have a vision for Germany. From the start, he said he didn't have detailed policies. Here's him giving another speech:
And when they say "What is your detailed program?" I can only answer: After a government with your kind of economy, with your kind of administration, your decay, the German people have to be rebuilt from top to bottom. We do not want to lie. We do not want to cheat. Therefore, I have refused ever to appear in front of this people and make cheap promises.
Hitler wanted Germans to give him weapons to rebuild the German Army. Re-Armament became his economic priority.
The Nazis increased the Army's budget so much in it's first year of power that the Army couldn't even spend it all.
They promised to rid Germany of unemployment. And they did. Mainly through huge work creation schemes, like the Autobahn-building program.
Johannes Zahn: the building of the autobahn's didn't result in a single pack of coffee or in a single bread roll being put up for sale in a shop window. Both were financed on an inflationary basis. At first, the population didn't see this, because the understanding of these monetary connections is too complex for the man on the street.
It would take time for the inflation pressure to be felt, but for the moment, shit was ROSY!
Especially in 1936, when Hitler ordered German troops to enter the de-militarized zone of Germany- the Rhineland.
There was little national protest. Germans were gaining their self-respect. The Olympic Games were held in Berlin that year.
Erna Krantz (resident of Munich): It definitely was a positive thing. Why, otherwise, did the masses follow this man? Why? There must have been a reason. That's the way it was. A lot of things got better. Things were improving.
The Nazis organized pageants, like THE NIGHT OF THE AMAZONS, which had naked babes, garish costumes, horses, flames, spectacles, all to entertain.
part V: THE ROAD TO TREBLINKA
This episode is just as grim as the last one. Maybe even more so.
We're told as late as 1940 the Nazis still had no plan to execute the Jews. Up to then, Nazi planning was just expulsion of them.
Ideas are thrown around about what to do with the "Jewish Question". One idea was sending them to a tropical island, maybe Madagasgar.
In the Warsaw ghetto in Poland, Polish jews were imprisoned as a temporary measure while Nazis decided on their fate.
Jews were considered carriers of Bolshevism, and Germans had hated Communism since the 20's.
To Nazis, this wasn't just a normal war. This was a Crusade.
German soldiers knew the fight on the Eastern front was to be fought without rules- tanks, flamethrowers, and "if anyone moved they were shot" was the norm when Germans invaded Lithuania, Soviet territory. We see historic footage of sheer brutality, flamethrowers torching homes, buildings levelled to the ground, and a former German soldier tells us: We were ordered to torch the houses and destroy everything. If anyone came outside, they were shot at. The order from the top was to destroy everything and raze it to the ground. Anything moved-Bang! No scruples, only stubborness. Some of our people were really keen on it, to let them have it.
Goebbels made propaganda films that played in German theatres that told the German people what to think about the hundreds of thousands of Eastern Jews:
(narrator over footage of Jews en masse): "THESE ARE THE TYPES OF EASTERN JEWS WHO FLOODED EUROPE'S CITIES AFTER THE LAST WAR----PARASITES, UNDERMINING THEIR HOSTS COUNTRIES, THREATENING THOUSAND-YEAR-OLD CULTURES AND BRINGING WITH THEM CRIME, CORRUPTION AND CHAOS"
Hitler intended to colonize the captured territories in the East and eventually settle Germans there.
Special "Killing Squads" were now ordered to cleanse the area of "undesirables". They were given brutal directives:
The following are to be executed: all Officials of the Comintern, Officials of Senior and Middle rank, all of the extremists of the party, the central committee, the provincial and district commitees, the People's Commissars, or, Jews in the service of the party & the State. No steps are to be taken to interfere with the Purges that may be initiated by the Communist or Jewish elements in the occupied territories. On the contrary, these are to be encouraged.
The murder of select Commies and Jews was seen as a "Quantum Leap". Hitler always said that Jews were behind Communism.
This crusade in the East was an attempt to crush Both.
There were 4 killing squads, and each had between 600-1000 men assigned. Each squad was led by an educated German.
When Germans arrived in Lithuania, once again they were seen as Liberators. Throughout Lithuania symbols of Communism were destroyed, and another infamous massacre occured in Kaunas. Jews were bludgeoned to death with crowbars, and once they were all killed, a killer climbed on top of the bodies and played the national anthem on his accordian. People clapped. Indeed, they screamed during the massacre: BEAT THE JEWS! BEAT THE JEWS! We see photos of the horror.
We see footage of executions in Latvia- brutal. Every Jew was deemed a "military threat", and to justify killing children, Himmler made it known that the Nazis could not allow generations of Avengers to arise.
In 1941, Jewish executions increase- over 4400 in July, over 38,000 in August.
Himmler got a little worried about his killers when one of the "educated" Squad Leaders told him that the psychological effects of murder at such close quarters was affecting his men. So Himmler did experiments to find more humane ways of killing- Humane for the executioners, not the victims. The Nazis started to experiment with gas, and filmed their findings. Point-blank shooting executions kept on going, but gas chambers were on the way. The Killing Squads meticulously recorded their killlings. Records showed their numbers of murders dramatically increasing.
67 men. 370 women. 303 children- in one day in one town. In a nearby town, the killing book records 1,279 Jews murdered the same day. the next day, in Merkine, 831 killed. In the Baltic States, some 80% of the killing squads were made up of locals. They jumped on the anti-semitism bandwagon no problem! The interview with one of the killing squad killers is unreal. He has no remorse, he says he served 20 years for what he did.
The interviewer asks him: You soldiers who used to do the shooting- you were volunteers.
He replies: maybe you could call them volunteers, they certainly were given more vodka.
Q: More?
A: Yes. More and more. They drank it, then everyone becomes Braver. We would shoot them, give them up as lost, and that was it.
Q: Didn't you ever think you ought to refuse to shoot them?
A: This is all very difficult to explain today: whether to shoot or not to shoot. I do not know. The others did it because of their anger- they thought the Jews were very Selfish. What can I say?
Q: Imprisonment, that was an Official punishment. What does your conscience say?
A: I do not know. I am not going to answer such questions.
In the Autumn of 1941 Hitler conducted his invasion of the East from "THE WOLF'S LAIR", his HQ in a forest in east Prussia.
His talk was of annihilation. He said Leningrad should vanish from the surface of the earth. He was privately expressing his undying hatred of Jews: "That race of Criminals has on it's conscience the 2 million dead Germans of World War I. And now, already hundreds of thousands More" He talked of getting his revenge. Apparently he had said:
"If the Jews really manage to push America and Germany into war against each other, I will have No Mercy". The jews are never willing to sacrifice. They stay in the background and pull the strings. AND I WILL HAVE NO MERCY".
part VI: FIGHTING TO THE END
In 1943 German soldiers saw the enemy Soviet soldiers doing the impossible. And Winning.
Germany was losing the war.
This episode sums up what happened to the Nazi Regime from 1943-1945. It opens with explaining how Fascism was created in Italy, and how Mussolini was an inspiration to Hitler and the Nazis. Mussolini was the first Fascist Leader of a country in World History, and Hitler was greatly impressed. An Alliance with Rome and Berlin seemed completely natural. But on July 19, 1943 the unthinkable happened. Rome was bombed. The alliance with Nazi Germany was nothing but a disaster. We're told that during 4 years of war Italy was half-destroyed. Everybody understood then that the war was lost. Nearly 250,000 Italian troops were dead or missing.
Everybody had it on their minds to GET OUT, to not stay with Mussolini anymore. So the government voted to give the King control of the Armed Forces. The Italians had had enough of Mussolini, and on the 25th of July 1943 the King summoned him and told him he was dismissed.
He was arrested by the Italian police and taken to prison. Italians were Jubilant. Now they were free of Mussolini and could change sides to end up with the winners. They declared war on their former ally Nazi Germany, Betrayed a friend. Italians were obviously more moralistic than Germans.
There were Germans who felt that what was happening under this Nazi regime during the war was wrong and that Hitler must go, and some of them were in his own SS. A plot was hatched to assassinate Hitler, and it was almost pulled off. Gaining access to Hitler was not easy, as he conducted the war from THE WOLF'S LAIR in east-Prussia, and it was protected by minefields, barbed wire, and Hitler's loyal SS bodyguard.
One man stood up to attempt the assassination: Claus von Stauffenberg. He said he was the only one prepared to do it.
He was able to plant a bomb in a briefcase on July 20, 1944, at the Wolf's Lair, in the conference room.
The bomb exploded as Hitler was being briefed.
It destroyed the conference room, but the wood walls were able to absorb a lot of the force of the blast. Hitler was burned, and had minor scrapes and bruises. He escaped unharmed. Now the search was on for all who were involved in the assassination plot.
Claus von Stauffenberg was shot, along with others. That conspiracy to kill Hitler had to be done in complete secret. It was the only way it was possible to work. And it almost did.
Hitler was clearly rattled by this assassination attempt. He gave an address to Germans on the radio, and his voice is starkly different from all of the sound clips of him we heard previously here. He is shook up. You can hear it in his voice. He says living through the attack was proof of Providence. He would carry on with his Life's goal.
Many Germans were disgusted at the attempt on Hitler's life, that something like that could ever happen. Hitler gained a lot of sympathy for it.
The Army was outraged. Every soldier was ordered from then on to realize that they were now political soldiers. Hitler decided that the Army needed to be in the Nazi fold much more.
The war in the East was getting more and more brutal. Partisans were hung at every spot they were found. If the Nazis didn't like you or your face then you were hung instantly, on the spot.We see horrific photos of partisans hanging dead and Nazis putting nooses around their necks.
Soviet forces were making huge advances in the East, putting big pressure on the German Army.
The British and the Americans were fighting their way up through Italy, and Allied Forces in Britain were preparing for the D-Day invasion in France. But the war in the East was where Germans were suffering their greatest losses.
We're told that the crucial reason Germans fought to the end was that they felt their opponents were sub-human.
Nazis would shoot children in front of the women, and then shoot the women, we hear testimony (from German soldiers even) that these were inhuman acts, that Nazis were sadists. Everybody was shot dead with no mercy. They loved hearing the women and children screaming. We're told some sick puppies really got off on that.
One former German soldier tells us that he saw a fellow soldier go into a house that had two elderly people in it and shot them dead in their chairs. He came out of the house and he had a go at him, shouting "How can you do a thing like that??" His response was " The only good Russian is a dead Russian".
We're told this "War of Annihilation" made it hard to remove Hitler.
The entire Nazi Leadership was riddled with dislike for one another, with serious suspicion of each other. Hitler liked to give two people the same or relatively similar tasks, and it would create infighting. They fought each other to gain the Fuhrer's favour.
A former German soldier says that at the time, he saw Germans as an "Invincible Master Race". He says it was "Unbridled National Pride", that "We Were SOMEBODY"
In this new Germany, there were 7.5 million forced labourers, which is described here as "a unique form of slavery". 1 million, 700 thousand of them were Polish. We're told that a half-million slaves from the concentration camps suffered even more than the Polish workers. Auschwitz was infamous. There were two types of camps there: concentration camps for workers, and the extermination camp with its gas chambers.
We hear of the horror of new arrivals being selected to go to one or the other. Selection for the work camp was often only a postponement of death. The life expectancy for a slave worker in Auschwitz was three months. We hear testimony from one worker who survived. He says he wanted to live, and strived to do that. He wanted to live to see Germany destroyed.
Regular Germans didn't know what was happening at these camps, but they definitely knew that Germany had become a racist State.
Germans regularly stated that a true German was a racially superior being.
We learn that 400,000 foreigners signed up to the Waffen SS, and fought right alongside the Germans.
Many were motivated by one reason alone.
Jacques Leroy (Belgian Waffen SS volunteer 1943-45): It was the war, the war against Russia, against Communism and Bolshevism, that was the motive for all enlistments in Europe. There are ideologies that I find repulsive. Any ideology that manipulates the individual like Communism, is repulsive to me. One fought to Conquer. To gain back lost land. Gain land from the enemy. You fought hand to hand for it.
Mr. Leroy lost his arm and his eye during the war, and he begged to stay in the Waffen SS and the Nazis allowed him to.
He is asked why he begged to stay in.
He replies: So as not to fall into mediocrity. And to stay with my friends, not to lose contact with my comrades. And I felt fine. My wounds had healed. I lost an arm and my eye, but when you're young you're not as affected as an older person might be.
As the war entered it's final phase, Allied bombing intensified.
In the last 15 months of the war 350, 000 civilian Germans died as a result of the bombing raids. (Three times the amount of Germans dead in the 3 previous years of war).
Wolf Falck (What a Great name!) -German fighter pilot: Goebbels called them "Churchill's Murder Boys". They were aiming for a destroyed industrial Germany. So we have nothing to lose. And so, we fought on, for our people, for our country, to protect them.
Germans hated the bombings but it didn't hurt their will to keep fighting.
Plus there was a more powerful reason to keep fighting: a real Dread of the advancing Soviet forces.
Both sides had committed atrocities on one another (and we hear them here- I won't repeat them for you-they are too disturbing).
The Soviets learned from the Germans how to be absolutely vicious to their enemies. They flipped it on the Krauts.
The Soviets were regarded as subhumans, yet these subhumans were now forcing the German Army into retreats, something they had never practised for. And if you've never practiced retreats as an Army then guess what? You are in PURE FLIGHT.
German troops had to face reality about the military situation they were in: Masses and Masses of aircraft were bombing the shit out of their cities and towns. They didn't know if their homes still existed, if their families were all dead. It was, as they say in soldier-speak, "A big shit sandwich. Everybody has to take a bite".
If the troops knew how bad it was, then Hitler must've known too. And may know it's worse than the troops think. But perhaps he knew it was better than they thought. That's how the troops looked at it, that the Fuhrer must be looking at opportunites to end the war. And that they should just keep on fighting, do their duty. It was all you could do in that situation.
6 million odds and sods citizens (old and young) were cobbled together in Berlin with Goebbels giving a speech telling them that Germany
will forge on. It's a joke. Watch it and be stunned. A lot of those faces we see in the clips wouldn't last an hour in war, yet Germany is calling on them to fight. Shit was Wack!
The End Was Near for Germany.
An ex-SS Officer tells us that at the end, it was clear that Hitler was a mentally ill man, to the extent that he suffered from excessive self-identification with what was happening to his fellow Germans. We're told he really lived that out. He was convinced that after him, after National Socialism, Germans could not survive, that Germany was destined to collapse. That Officer heard it from his own lips, and he knew right then that Hitler was mentally ill. He also was suffering physical ailments. He had a shaking paralysis on his right side apparently, with bad eyesight and he walked with a shuffling gait.
But those problems did nothing to erase his "Demonic Charisma", and he was still the undisputed Leader of Germany.
Italians could rely on their King to oust Mussolini. But Hitler controlled all levers of power in Germany. Germans were stuck with him.
This episode ends with Hitler's suicide in a bunker, with Soviet troops just yards away.
(But I don't believe it. I believe Hitler escaped in a U-Boat with over 50 SS Officers and lived in Argentina until 1985)
That's a controversial theory, I admit it. But I believe it.