Results 1 to 3 of 3


  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jul 2002
    SF Bay Area


    From Pa negre/Black Bread (Agustí Villaronga)

    Wikipedia gives a List of submissions to the 84th Academy Awards for Best Foreign Language Film.

    Of the 65 in the list I've seen just over a dozen, and these are the ones and where I saw them:

    FINLAND Le Havre (Kaurasmaki, NYFF)
    GEORGIA Chantrapas (Osseliani, SFIFF)
    GERMANY Pina (Wenders, NYFF)
    GREECE Attenberg (Tsangari, ND/NF)
    HUNGARY The Turin Horse (Tarr, NYFF)
    IRAN A Separation (Farhadi NYFF)
    ISRAEL Footnote (Cedar, NYFF)
    LEBANON Where Do We Go Now? (Labaki, Paris)
    MEXICO Miss Bala (Naranjo, NYFF)
    NORWAY Happy, Happy (Sewitsky, ND/NF)
    PERU October (Vega and Vega, ND/NF)
    SPAIN Black Bread (Villaronga SFIIFF)
    TURKEY Once Upon a Time in Anatolia (Ceylan NYFF)

    I would say Black Bread is my favorite. But then I saw Miss Bala. For me it would be a tossup between those two. Footnote is interesting: a rousing psychological and political drama about Torah scholarship isn't something you run into every day. The Turin Horse and Once Upon a Time in Anatolia are cinephile favorites by prestigious directors, but I don't personally like them. I go against the pack also on A Separation. It seems to be universally admired by those who see it and I can grant its cunning construction and its very Iranian vision, but it does not appeal to me. One notes, by the way, that the New York Film Festival seems to be very good at picking national bests. Of course this is a list from a much longer list but will be narrowed down to only five by the Academy. And then they'll pick one. Is that fair? and does it make sense? Not very; and not so much.

    Black Bread is not just Spanish, by the way: it's Catalan.

    Let me know if any of you have seen others on the list and what you thought of them and if there are other titles you think are more deserving of making the list.
    Last edited by Chris Knipp; 11-08-2011 at 10:11 AM.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Oct 2002
    Thanks for this thread CK. After a change in viewing habits over the past year or so, I'm no longer up to date when it comes to contemporary cinema. Perhaps Howard has seen some of these Oscar-submission films. I've only seen Happy, Happy although others from the list have had screenings around town.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jul 2002
    SF Bay Area
    Thanks for checking in.

    The Italy entry is Crialese's Terraferma. It was shown here in a New Italian series but I was not present. I wonder if it is as good as Alice Rohrwacher's debut film, Corpo Celeste, which was in the NYFF and impressed me quote a bit (though I'm not sure I'd give it the Best Foreign prize).


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts