CANNES Festival 2019

[Chris Knipp]

August Diehl in A Hidden Life

A Hidden Life (Terrence Malick). Competition.

David Erlich of IndieWire says this is his best movie since Tree of Life but the material is different: the true story of Austrian farmer turned conscientious objector Franz Jägerstätter, who refused to take the Hitler oath as a Wehrmacht conscript and in 1943 was duly executed. No battlefields, the war simply between a Christian and his conscience. Bradshaw says in the Guardian that it's "a high-minded hymn to modern saint that never quite comes to life" and gives it 3 our of 5 stars. This still has the Malilckian swirling camera and meditative mood, as Bradshaw describes it, with "An overpowering sense of being ecstatically, epiphanically in the present moment," with the "camera shots swooning, swooping and looming around the characters who appear often to be lost in thought, to an orchestral or organ accompaniment, and a murmured voiceover narration of the characters’ intimate but distinctly abstract feelings and memories." The problem is that the swoony approach has, Bradshaw says, "marooned and islanded Jägerstetter," cutting him off from the all-important historical moment and resultingly making his anguish as generic as that of Bale in Knight of Cups or Afflick in To the Wonder, though the stakes are so much higher here, and the details should be so much more distinctive. Peter Debruge oin Variety acknowledges this film works best for the Malick fan, but affirms that it's his best since Tree of Life and "feels stunningly relevant" about religionists selling out for political advantage.


Diego Maradona in the film by Asif Kapadia

Diego Maradona (Asif Kapadia). Out of Competition.

By the maker of the Amy Winehouse doc, this is, by many reports, a stunningly effective film about the poor boy from Buenos Aires who became the successor to Pele as the god of soccer, and his eventual fall from grace. HIs '86 World Cup "Hand of God" winning goal, photos show, was hand-assisted, which a commentator calls "a little bit of cheating and a lot of genius," and that goes for his career, says Eric Kohn in IndieWire (he gives it an A-). The path to downfall is multiple, including an extra-marital affair and child, involvement with a crime family, and a drug bust. Sometimes details come too fast even in over two hours, says Kohn, but Kapadia still keeps it hypnotically watchable. The account is "gripping," says Bradshaw in his enthusiastic Guardian review (he gives it 4 out of 5 stars) even though hampered by a lack of the kind of new material he had for his Winehouse film. Owen Gleiberman of Variety goes farther, says it all doesn't make sense to him, and Kapadia tries to reach for the stars, but doesn't have the revealing material to do "what he did for the fallen idols of 'Amy' and 'Senna'." A different fan base for an audience, though.


Fabrice Luchini, Anaïs Demoustier in Alice and the Mayor

Alice and the Mayor (Nicolas Pariser). Directors Fortnight.

Alice et le maire (the French title) is the sophomore effort of the French director who debuted with the subtle, understated political thriller The Great Game/Le grand jeu (R-V 2016) in which key players follow Nietsche's advice, "Whatever is profound loves masks." That seems to be a favorite saying of Fabrice Lucchini, the mayor of this new film, mayor of the city of Lyon, who after 30 years of politics is totally out of ideas. Sparks fly and preconceptions are shaken when he's provided with Alice Heinemann (Anaïs Demoustier), a brilliant philosophy scholar, to inspire him. Jay Weissberg of Variety thinks the result is far too talky, and Boyd van Hoeij of Hollywood reporter thinks Pariser can't decide if he wants to focus on ideas or people. He grants that Pariser, who studied with Eric Rohmer, handles the talk well. He thinks the rapport between the middle-aged mayor and the young teacher is fascinating, but has nowhere to go and ultimately stagnates. We'll have to see what French critics, who may appreciate the talk more, think of this movie when it hits French cinemas in October.


Camille Cottin, Vincent Lacoste, Chiara Mastroianni in Chambre 212

On a Magical Night/Chambre 212 (Christophe Honoré). Un Certain Regard.

Stephen Dalton says in Hollywood Reporter that this came just at the right time midway in the Cannes Festival when attendees much needed a "frothy" "bed-hopping" French farce as a "palate-cleanser." "Christophe Honore’s bittersweet comic fantasy stars Chiara Mastroianni as a highly sexed college lecturer weighing up the steep cost of loving," Dalton writes. Suppose, the film fantasizes, you could go back a few decades to your spouse in his youthful prime, would you still like him, knowing how jaded you'll get later on? A great "springboard into screwball comedy and counterfactual fantasy," says Dalton, even if Honoré gets his plot-line a bit muddled. Vincent Lacoste plays the young version of haughty oversexed prof Chiara Mastroianni's mature hubby played by Benjamin Biolay. This is a top cast. Honoré doesn't quite know how to end, says Dalton, but the final sequence, where Chiara and all her former lovers, including both the young and old version of her husband, meet at a bar and dance away the night to Barry Manilow, is a "patently dumb notion" that nonetheless delivers "a perverse kind of pleasure." It all may be too French for outside audiences, but the setup is readymade for a Hollywood remake.

[Chris Knipp]

Today, 20 May 2019 at the Cannes Film Festival.


NOÉMIE MERLANT, ADÈLE HAENEL IN PORTRAIT OF A LADY ON FIRE

Portrait of a Lady on Fire (Céline Sciamma).

Céline Sciamma has built a distinguished reputation in the past 12 years for fresh and original femme-centric films, sometimes with a trans or gay bent. Portrait de la jeune fille en feu (the French title) is set in 1770 and concerns a painter, Marianne (Noémie Merlant), who must paint the marriage portrait of Héloïse (Adèle Haenel, of Sciamma's debut Water Lilies), the young daughter of a countess who has just left a convent. Peter Debruge in Variety calls this "a gorgeous, slow-burn lesbian romance." Héloïse is uncooperative. Her mother, the countess, orders Marianne to observe her during the day and work on her portrait at night, so she must devour her with her large eyes. The mutual fascination that develops eventually turns physical. The result is a subtle, nuanced depiction of the female gaze that only a woman could paint, Debruge says. Peter Bradshaw heralds the film in his Guardian review as "superbly elegant, enigmatic drama," that reveals the director's "new mastery of classical style." He gives it his top rating, 5 out of 5 stars.


VICTORIA BLUCK AND IDIR BEN ADDI IN YOUNG AHMED

Young Ahmed (Luc and Jean-Pierre Dardenne). Competition.

Le jeune Ahmed (the French title) is about a Belgian teenager (the actor, Idir Ben Addi, was 13) of paternal Moroccan Arab descent but with a white non-muslim mother (whose husband is no longer around) who hatches a plot to kill his teacher after being taught a radical interpretation of the Quran. Leslie Felperin of Hollywood Reporter thinks Addi a "blank" actor like those of the Dardennes' earlier films that won them two Golden Palms, but neither she nor the Variety critic thinks this quite up to their strongest work, though better than their blandest: Eric Kohn of IndieWire places it midway on the spectrum. Bradshaw thinks this (like Sciamma's new film) "subtle". He gives it 3 out of 5 stars. Ahmed goes from video games to jihad in the space of a month and begins lecturing his mother and sister on their behavior. Ahmed attacks his teacher for too liberal an approach to teaching the Quran, and is put in youth custody. He may rethink, or more likely not. A work release meeting on a farm with an attractive girl who likes him could make a difference. Bu how he will develop is uncertain. The movie is marred, says Bradshaw, by a silly chase sequence used to jazz things up for an artificial conclusion. Peter Debruge of Variety suggests that as a sympathetic (if ambiguous) portrait of a budding Islamic terrorist, this may be the Dardennes’ "most controversial film yet." It sounds at least like one of their most puzzling.

[Chris Knipp]

Also May 20.

Two portraits of two women



An Easy Girl (Rebecca Zlotkowsk). Directors Fortnight.

Une fille facile (the French title), is a watchable film, "Rohmer for the instagram age," says Screen Daily of this fourth film by the director who effectively pared Tahar Rahim and Léa Seydoux for her film Grand Central. This time it is two sisters, who pair off for the summer in Cannes, when the younger one (Mina Farid) is drawn into the luxurious ways of her older sister (actress, model and lingerie designer Dehar), with Benoît Magimel also in the cast.


ERRADI AND AZABAL IN ADAM

Adam (Maryam Touzani). Un Certain Regard.

Moroccan filmmaker Maryam Touzani's debut feature turns "a simple story" into "gold" with its warm depiction of a homeless unwed pregnant woman and the widowed small bakery owner who befriends her, says Deborah Young in her Hollywood Reporter review. Set in Casablanca’s Old Medina, it's a tale that allows the actors time to make delicate transitions, and a main one is the bakery owner's gradual softening toward the pregnant woman.


ISABELLE HUPPERT IN FRANKIE

Frankie (Ira Sachs). Competition.

Peter Bradshaw makes it immediately clear that he hated this film with a Guardian critique headed "Frankie review – Ira Sachs' bickering poshos bore us to tears," and he gave it an almost unprecedented 1 out of 5 stars.David Rooney of Hollywood Reporter says it "offers many gentle pleasures," a main one being the mountainous Portuguese scenery for which Sachs has left left behind his New York settings (it's like a bland Woody Allen location film, Bradshaw comments, but without the humor). And yet the longtime indie director has assembled an A-List cast here. Huppert is supported by the likes of Greg Kinnear, Brendan Gleeson, Jérémie Renier and Marisa Tomei. Bradshaw acknowledges Sachs' recent Little Men (2016) and Love Is Strange (2014) have been superb, so he can't fathom how he could have laid an egg "so big that the walls of the Palais des Festivals may have be knocked down so it can be safely removed." The premise: Francoise (Frankie, Huppert), a film and TV star, has brought her family to the Portuguese town of Sintra for a luxurious holiday to tell them something, but this is complicated when one of them takes the opportunity to propose marriage to another member of the party. Rooney acknowledges that this is a "sedate" and "gossamer-thin" effort lacking the "emotional complexity" and "intense personal investment" of Sachs' best work. But he supposes that its "classy old-school art house veneer" will make it sell as a fall Sony Picture Classics release.


HAFSIA HERZI IN YOU DESERVE A LOVER]

You Deserve a Lover (Hafsia Herzi). Critics Week.

Tu mérites un amour (the French title) features Hafsia Herzi in front of and behind the camera in (says Screen Daily) "a brisk, energetic low-budget tale of a Parisienne’s romantic trials and tribulations." "A brisk femme-positive approach and the personal urgency that comes with Hafsia Herzi’s energetic, no-bullshit presence", and it's her directorial debut. She became known playing the lead in Abdellatif Kechiche's Secret of the Grain. The story's all about Lila (the protagonist played by director Hirzi) coming to accept that her boyfriend who dumped her wasn't worth it anyway. "Some of the dialogue is wickedly pungent," says Deborah Young in her Hollywood Reporter review. Naturalness, warmth, humor, a relaxed pace as well as a very modern frankness about sex (and the director-star's beauty and personal charm) make this otherwise conventional Parisian screen entertainment stand out from the crowd.

[Chris Knipp]

Cannes May 21, 2019

MOST ANTICIPATED EVENT today is the showing of Quentin Tarantino's new movie, Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood, about some down-on-their luck actors at the time of the Sharon Tate murders, with Bruce Lee and Charles Manson as incidental characters and starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Brad Pitt. Tarantino has posted an open letter to all Cannes writers and attendees about spoilers - asking all not to give away stuff. See the letter H E R E.

Bradshaw calls Gaspar Noë's Lux Æterna "self-parodic silliness" and gives it 2 out of 5 stars.


BENNY EMMANUEL, GABRIEL CARBAJAL IN CHICUAROTES

Chicuarotes (Gael García Bernal). Special Screenings.

This is the second directorial outing from Gael García Bernal, a long time since the first (2007), and a disappointment, says Screen Daily's Jonathan Romney. That debut was Deficit , a "coolly ironic depiction of Mexico’s spoiled middle-class youth," This one, explains Romney, returns "more or less" to Amores Perros territory (the film that brought him international recognition as an actor), depicting "two young working-class chancers desperate to improve their lot" who wind up "screwing up in every way." It's like a "WhatsApp-era Los Olvidados, with "energy to spare" but a "tonal discontinuity" that "scuppers the film," oscillating between "goofy comedy, hard-nosed violence and wildly overplayed melodrama."

[Chris Knipp]

Screen Daily's jury grid.

Yesterday's showed Almodóvar's Pain and Glory in the lead of critics' ratings (3.3), then Portrait of a Lady on Fire (3.1), Atlantics (2.8), Wild Goose Lake (2.7), Bacaru (2.6), and Les Misérables (2.4). Malick, Polombiu and Loach all got the same in-between score (2.5). Jim Jarmusch's opener The Dead Don't Die scored lowest (2.2).

[Chris Knipp]

LEO DICAPRIO IN ONCE UPON A TIME...IN HOLLYWOOD

Once Upon a Time... in Hollywood (Quentin Tarantino). Competition.

Controversial, but likely to be up there in ratings, Quentin Tarantino's ninth feature, set in 1969, premiered today on the 25th anniversary of Pulp Fiction's triumphant Cannes opening (it won the Palme d'Or and made the director famous), and the new film is felt by some to have structural and other affinities to the earlier one. A "shocking, gripping, dazzlingly shot" movie, Peter Bradshaw writes in a 5-out-of-5-star Guardian review, "in the celluloid-primary colors of sky blue and sunset gold." He will not reveal the shocking finale. The period is "recovered with all Tarantino’s habitual intensity and delirious, hysterical connoisseurship of pop culture detail," says Bradshaw, with a new thing, not just cinephilia but "TVphilia", with lots about the small screen of the time, an aspect Richard Lawson is particularly interested in in his Vanity Fair review. Rick Dalton, the alcoholic actor played by DiCaprio, becomes a has-been when his TV western series is cancelled. Cliff Booth (Brad PItt) is his stunt double, factotum, and only friend. They live in the shadow of the Manson murders, which have not yet occurred. Sharon Tate is Rick's neighhbor. The cast includes Al Pacino and Margot Robbie. Robbie Collin, in his Telegraph review, likewise gives the movie 5 out of 5 stars and calls it "pure movie-world intoxication," giving more details of its relationship to the Sharon Tate murders - which some believe is when the Hollywood dream ended with a crash. "There’s a gleeful toxicity here that will launch a thousand think-pieces," writes Collin. "Pitt’s character is capital-P problematic, absolutely by design." "But," he concludes, "the transgressive thrill is undeniable, and the artistry mesmerisingly assured." Tweets are enthusiastic, and praise is being heaped on Margot Robbie as Sharon Tate. Al Pacino reportedly has a hilarious cameo as Dalton's agent. "This curious fairy tale may not be the truth, and it may prattle on too long, writes Lawson in Vanity Fair. "But when its stars align, and they let loose with their unmistakable shine, Hollywood movies do seem truly special again. And, sure, maybe TV does too."Justin Chang in his LA Times review calls this a "richly evocative, conceptually jaw-dropping, excessively foot-fetishizing, inescapably terrifying and unexpectedly poignant movie."


MARGOT ROBBIE AS SARON TATE IN ONCE UPON A TIME...IN HOLLYWOOD [Sony Pictures Releasing]

[Chris Knipp]

PARK SO-DAM, CHOI WOO0SIK IN PARASITE

Parasite (Bong Joon-ho). Competition.

Parasite/(기생충 (Gisaengchung) is "a pitch-black tragicomedy about economic inequality in modern Korea," Jessica Kiang explains in her Variety review. His past filmography - Snowpiercer, Memories of Murder, The Host and Okja - shows Bong to be a genre unto himself, says IndieWire's David Erlich. Peter Bradshaw (who elsewhere compares it to Joseph Losey's The Servant)calls this film "a bizarre black comedy," "satirical suspense drama," a "creepy invasion of the lifestyle snatchers" set in "a modern-day 'Downton Abbey situation" that "gets its tendrils into you." He gives it 4 out of 5 stars in his Guardian review. There's a resemblance to Hirakazu Koreeda's Palme d'Or-winning Shoplifters in that here there is an impoverished family that hides its relationships, in this case to rob an ultra-rich family. The invading poor family burns with resentment and wants to take on a lifestyle that they think should be theirs. This is at once Bong's "most tightly plotted" and " most formally polished work," says Kiang, and proceeds seamlessly and with finely crafted settings with "a watchmaker’s skill" In the way it keeps "the pendulum of our sympathies swinging back and forth between the grasping desperation of the poor and the idle hatefulness of the rich."

Looks like Parasite will take a high spot on Screen Daily's Jury Grid - where, incidentally, Tarantino's new film got four 4.0's but averaged 3.0, in third place below Pain and Glory and Portrait of a Lady on Fire, because big fans it also had scoffers and a hater, having received a 3, two 2's and a zero (the latter from Die Zeit's Katja Nicodemus). Nonetheless Once Upon a Time in Hollywood has current Metacritic score of 86%. (Cannes press conference for Tarantino: H E R E.)

The post-Tarantino Screen Daily jury grid: