How your argue your evaluation of a movie is the key, of course, but some people have more interesting opinions than others as well as more convincing ways of defending them.

I'm glad you found I'm Not There worthy of interest and I hope you can make a contribution to discussion of it, if not now, later on. The threads remain open.

When you find all these faults with Control, maybe you can understand why sometimes I find so many faults with literary adaptations--the same principles apply. But not No Country for Old Men!.