I don't think that I'm advocating a structure-less conversation of films. I'm asking what is admissible and what's not in a discussion of films...

For instance, if I were to discuss Eyes Wide Shut, I would talk about its views of human sexuality, infidelity and fidelity, and its worldview perspectives. I would ask if Eyes Wide Shut presents a coherent and informative discussion on these topics and then I might draw into the debate other films (or books, etc.) that take a different perspective on similar issues. Would this be appropriate for FilmWurld? Or, am I simply limited to discussing Kubrick's cinematography and direction?

Same thing with F9/11... why was it suddenly taken as inappropriate to talk about politics, Iraq, and other related issues?